What Is a Co-op Commission in Real Estate, and Does It Still Exist in California in 2026?
A co-op commission (short for "cooperating broker compensation") was the share of a listing broker's fee that the listing broker offered to the broker who brought the buyer. Until August 17, 2024, that offer was published on every MLS listing in California. It no longer is: under the National Association of Realtors settlement, "offers of compensation are no longer allowed on Multiple Listing Service platforms," and the California Regional MLS removed its compensation fields on August 8 and 13, 2024. As an offer made by the seller's side, the co-op commission is gone: in 2026 sellers do not offer a commission to a buyer's agent. The buyer signs a written agreement with their own agent first, and the buyer's offer may ask the seller to pay some or all of that fee, a request the seller can accept, counter or decline like any other term. Here is how it works now, with the current numbers.
What was a co-op commission, and what changed in 2024?
Traditionally the seller agreed to a total commission with the listing broker, and the listing broker offered a portion to any cooperating broker who produced the buyer. NAR's consumer guide defines an offer of compensation as the seller or seller's agent agreeing to "compensate another agent for bringing a buyer to successfully close the transaction." The practice changes that took effect August 17, 2024 did three things: removed those offers from the MLS, required MLS participants to sign written agreements with buyers before touring homes, and left compensation "fully negotiable." Sellers do not offer a commission to a buyer's agent; a buyer's offer may ask the seller to pay some or all of it.
The settlement was approved at a hearing before Judge Stephen Bough on November 26, 2024 (final judgment entered January 2025), and a three-judge panel of the Eighth Circuit affirmed it on August 19, 2026. Objectors have sought further review, so the appellate record is not fully closed, but the practice rules have been in force for more than two years. The U.S. Department of Justice went further than the settlement in its filings: in June 2025 it withdrew its objections to a parallel MLS settlement in Massachusetts while stating that "blanket, upfront offers of buyer broker compensation" are anticompetitive, and its December 2025 statement in a Pennsylvania case argued that association and MLS rules should be judged as per se antitrust violations. No 2026 DOJ filing on offers of compensation has appeared.
How does the buyer's agent get paid in California now?
In one of three ways, and often a combination:
The buyer's offer asks the seller to pay. The buyer's offer asks the seller to pay the buyer's broker a stated amount. C.A.R.'s Residential Purchase Agreement carries this request in paragraph 3G(3), and the Seller's Payment to Buyer's Broker form (SPBB) documents it. The seller can accept, counter or decline that request like price or any other term; nothing requires a seller to agree.
The listing broker shares its fee. A listing broker may agree in writing, outside the MLS, to pay part of its own fee to the buyer's broker. That is an agreement between the two brokers, not an offer by the seller.
The buyer pays directly. Whatever the seller does not cover, the buyer owes under their representation agreement.
Lender rules make the first route workable. Fannie Mae's April 15, 2024 notice says seller-paid buyer-agent commissions that follow local custom "are not required to be counted towards the IPC limits," the caps on seller contributions to a buyer's costs; Freddie Mac issued matching guidance the same day. FHA said the same in FHA INFO 2024-12 (March 28, 2024). The VA, which had barred veterans from paying buyer-broker fees, issued Circular 26-24-14 allowing them to pay "reasonable and customary" buyer-broker charges effective August 10, 2024, though the fee cannot be financed into the loan.
What does California law require?
California added its own rules on top of the settlement. Civil Code §1670.50 (AB 2992, effective January 1, 2025) requires a buyer-broker agreement "as soon as practicable, but no later than the execution of the buyer's offer," caps the term at three months, bans automatic renewal, and makes a non-compliant agreement "void and unenforceable." Business and Professions Code §10147.5 requires every listing agreement, and since AB 2992 every buyer agreement and purchase contract with a compensation term, to carry the bold notice that commissions "are not fixed by law" and are negotiable; the section was amended again by AB 1521 effective January 1, 2026. The Department of Real Estate's consumer alert (amended December 12, 2024) puts it plainly: "Commissions are fully negotiable under California law," and an agent who claims a "standard" rate is misrepresenting the law.
What are buyer's agents actually being paid in 2026?
Clever Real Estate's August 2026 agent survey puts the California average at 5.08% total, 2.57% listing and 2.51% buyer's agent, against a national 5.46% (2.76% / 2.70%). The California figure rests on 50 agents, so treat it as a guide rather than a benchmark. On the state's $899,720 September median (C.A.R.), those rates are real money:
Buyer's agent at 2.51%: $22,583
Listing agent at 2.57%: $23,123
Total at 5.08%: $45,706
Buyer's agent at a negotiated 2%: $17,994; at 1.5%: $13,496
The share of transactions involving agents has not fallen. NAR's 2026 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers (November 5, 2026) found 90% of buyers purchased through an agent and a record 92% of sellers used one; for-sale-by-owner fell to 5%. What the public data does not show is the split between seller-paid and buyer-paid compensation; NAR's press release carries no such figure, so any claim about "most sellers still pay" is anecdote.
How Properkey handles it
Properkey lists homes for a $0 listing fee with full MLS exposure, pro photos and a 3D tour, and a dedicated agent from list to close. Sellers do not offer a commission to a buyer's agent. A buyer's offer may ask the seller to pay one in paragraph 3G(3) of the purchase agreement; that is not required, and the seller can accept, counter or decline it like any other term. On a $899,720 home, a seller who accepts a 2.51% buyer-broker request and pays no listing commission pays $22,583 in total commission instead of the $45,706 average, as Properkey's guide to negotiating commission in California lays out. Buyers working with Properkey's buyer service sign the state-required agreement up front, so the fee is known before the first showing.
Questions people ask
Is a co-op commission illegal now? Publishing an offer of compensation on an MLS is prohibited by the settlement and by CRMLS Rule 7.15, and sellers no longer offer one. A seller agreeing in the purchase contract to a buyer's request to pay the buyer's broker is lawful, and so is a written agreement between the two brokers outside the MLS.
Does the seller have to pay the buyer's agent in California? No. Nothing in state law or the settlement requires it. The request comes in the buyer's offer and is negotiated like price or any other term: the seller can accept it, counter it or decline it.
Can a buyer's commission be rolled into the mortgage? Not directly. A seller-paid fee is simply part of the seller's costs; a buyer-paid fee is cash at closing. Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and FHA do not count a customary seller-paid buyer-agent fee against the seller-contribution limits; VA allows the veteran to pay the fee but not to finance it.
Where can a buyer see whether a seller will pay? CRMLS listings no longer carry a compensation field. They do carry a yes/no indicator that a seller "may consider a buyer concession if made in an offer," and any concession language sits in the public remarks. Ask the listing agent, then put the request in writing in the offer.
This article summarizes published rules and survey data as of November 6, 2026 and is not legal advice. Commission rates are negotiable and vary by transaction.
Sources: NAR settlement facts · NAR consumer guide: offers of compensation · CRMLS settlement resources · Real Estate News, 8th Circuit ruling · RISMedia, DOJ June 2025 · Civ. Code §1670.50 · B&P §10147.5 · DRE consumer alert · Fannie Mae notice, Apr 15, 2024 · FHA INFO 2024-12 · VA Circular 26-24-14 (via ALTA) · C.A.R. BRBC/SPBB guide · Clever, California commission rates · Clever, US commission rates · NAR 2026 Profile · C.A.R. September 2026 sales
Written by Keyro, Properkey's AI. Properkey, DRE #01979718.
