Who Pays the Buyer's Agent Commission in California in 2026? What the Numbers Say Two Years After the NAR Settlement
October 29, 2026. Two years after the rules changed, "who pays the buyer's agent" is still the first question most California sellers and buyers ask. The short answer: the fee is negotiated in the offer, sellers still usually end up covering some or all of it, and the typical rates did not fall. Here is what the data shows and what it means for your sale or purchase.
What changed in August 2024
The National Association of Realtors settled the Sitzer-Burnett commission lawsuits in March 2024 for $418 million, after a jury verdict of $1.78 billion in October 2023. The practice changes took effect August 17, 2024: offers of buyer-agent compensation can no longer be published on the MLS, and a buyer must sign a written agreement with their agent before touring homes. The court gave final approval in November 2024, and the Eighth Circuit upheld the settlement on August 19, 2026 and denied rehearing on September 24 (Clever, 2026).
California added its own rule. AB 2992, effective January 1, 2025, requires every buyer-broker agreement to be in writing, to state the agent's compensation, services and expiration date, and to expire no more than three months after signing. The buyer can pay the agent directly or ask the seller to cover some or all of the fee as a concession; if the seller says no, the buyer remains responsible (California Department of Real Estate consumer alert, December 2024).
What buyers' agents are actually charging in 2026
The prediction was that buyer-agent fees would fall toward 1.5% to 2%. They did not. Clever's August 2026 survey of 434 agents puts the national average buyer's agent commission at 2.70%, up from 2.58% in 2024 and about where it was in 2021. The national average total commission is 5.46%. California is lower than the country, as it has been for decades: 5.08% total, 2.57% to the listing side and 2.51% to the buyer's side (Clever, updated October 1, 2026). A Federal Reserve staff note from May 2025 found the same long pattern: buyer-agent rates drifted from about 3% in the late 1990s to about 2.7%, and they run lowest in California, the Northeast and the Pacific Northwest, where prices are highest.
Who writes the check has changed less than the headlines suggested. In Clever's 2026 survey, 73% of agents said sellers in their market are likely to cover the buyer's agent's fee when a buyer's offer asks, and only 28% said commissions in their market have compressed since the settlement. The request now comes from the buyer in the purchase offer, not from the seller in the MLS.
What that means on a California sale
Apply the 2026 California averages to C.A.R.'s September statewide median of $899,720 (C.A.R., October 19, 2026). A typical listing-side fee of 2.57% is about $23,100. A typical buyer-side fee of 2.51% is about $22,600. A seller who agrees to both pays roughly $45,700 before title, escrow and transfer taxes.
Properkey lists homes for $0 commission on the listing side, with the MLS and CRMLS entry, syndication to every portal, professional photography, a 3D tour, drone aerials and a floor plan included. The buyer's agent fee is separate: sellers do not offer it, a buyer's offer may ask you to pay some or all of it, and you can accept, counter or decline that request. In today's market, where Redfin counts 62.6% more sellers than buyers nationally and seven of California's eight largest metros are buyer's markets (Redfin, October 14, 2026), a seller who declines every such request is competing against sellers who agree to them. The practical question is not whether to pay anything, but what agreeing buys you in offers.
If you are the buyer
Read the agreement before you sign it. Under AB 2992 it must state the fee, and under the settlement that fee is the most your agent can collect from any source for that purchase. A buyer who agrees to 2.5% and then asks the seller to cover it is not paying twice; the seller's concession goes toward the same fee. Three months is the maximum term, so a slow search means re-signing, which is also a natural point to renegotiate. If an agent presents the fee as fixed by law or by the MLS, that is wrong on both counts.
The settlement money
Sellers who closed in the covered period had until May 9, 2025 to file claims against the NAR settlement and the related brokerage settlements, which total roughly $1 billion including the $110.6 million Gibson settlements the Eighth Circuit affirmed this fall. A separate homebuyer settlement, Tuccori, had a claim deadline of October 27, 2026, with a final approval hearing set for November 2, 2026 (Clever, 2026). If you sold or bought through a large brokerage in those years, check the settlement administrators' sites before assuming you are out of time.
Properkey's practice: $0 listing commission, every listing in the MLS and on every portal from day one, and a straight answer on the buyer-agent fee instead of a percentage presented as a rule. Details at properkey.us/sell. This article summarizes public data and law as of October 29, 2026; it is not legal or financial advice.
Sources: Clever Real Estate, "Average Real Estate Agent Commission Rates" (August 2026 survey, updated October 1, 2026) and "NAR Lawsuit: What's Changed for Commissions 2 Years Later" (2026); Federal Reserve, FEDS Notes, "Commissions and Omissions: Trends in Real Estate Broker Compensation" (May 12, 2025); California Department of Real Estate, Consumer Alert on AB 2992 (amended December 12, 2024); C.A.R., September 2026 Home Sales and Price Report (October 19, 2026); Redfin, sellers vs. buyers, September 2026 (October 14, 2026).
Written by Keyro, Properkey's AI. Properkey, DRE #01979718.
